Skip to content

ADA Website Compliance Lawsuits: 2023 Recap

In 2023, the landscape of digital accessibility underwent significant scrutiny, as reflected by the surge in website accessibility lawsuits. These legal actions primarily hinged on Title III of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), reinforcing the mandate that digital services, including websites, should be accessible to individuals with disabilities. In particular, organizations with an annual revenue of under $25 million found themselves the primary targets, pointing to a trend where smaller businesses are being held to the same standards as their larger counterparts.

This rise in litigation underscores a growing emphasis on digital inclusivity, with a variety of industries coming under the legal microscope. Among them, food and restaurant websites witnessed nearly half of the total website compliance lawsuits in California. The statistics suggest a pattern where certain sectors are more susceptible to challenges regarding online accommodation for disabled users.

Although the number of plaintiffs is extensive, a relatively small group is responsible for a substantial portion of the actions brought forward. This dynamic indicates a concentration in advocacy and enforcement efforts by a few toward ensuring ADA compliance in the digital domain. The prevalence of website accessibility lawsuits continues to shape the conversation around what it means to be inclusive in the modern digital age, proving that accessibility is not just a feature, but a fundamental aspect of online presence.

Ada Compliant

Exploring the Basics of ADA Website Compliance

The realm of ADA website compliance is anchored in understanding the legal requirements and implications for digital accessibility. This section dissects what constitutes an ADA-compliant website and the intrinsic components that ensure online spaces are navigable for all users.

What Is an ADA-Compliant Website?

An ADA-compliant website meets the standards set forth under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). This legislation requires that websites offer equitable access to individuals with disabilities, thereby eschewing potential discrimination. Compliance encompasses a diverse range of considerations designed to make web content and functionality accessible to people with a spectrum of disabilities, including auditory, cognitive, neurological, physical, speech, and visual impairments.

In the pursuit of compliance, websites must adhere to the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG), which delineate how to make web content more accessible. The current standard, WCAG 2.1, is organized around four principles, often known by the acronym POUR:

  • Perceivable: Information and user interface components must be presentable to users in ways they can perceive.
  • Operable: User interface components and navigation must be operable.
  • Understandable: Information and the operation of the user interface must be understandable.
  • Robust: Content must be robust enough to be interpreted reliably by a wide variety of user agents, including assistive technologies.

For legal compliance, it is paramount that websites do not just aim for accessibility, but actively implement and maintain accessible features. Continuous monitoring and updates are necessary as technology and standards evolve. Failure to comply with the ADA can result in litigation, making it imperative for website owners to rigorously evaluate and rectify accessibility issues.

The legal requirements of ADA website compliance are enforced through lawsuits that assert the rights of individuals with disabilities. In 2023, an uptick in ADA website compliance lawsuits was noted, which highlights the need for proactive measures in digital accessibility. Equally important is an understanding that ADA compliance is not just a one-time effort but an ongoing commitment to inclusivity.

Screen Displaying Accesible

Legal Landscape and Accessibility Legislation

In the year 2023, the legal landscape governing website accessibility has significantly evolved. Entities that operate websites have faced a notable shift in compliance expectations, heavily influenced by pertinent legislation and resulting legal actions.

U.S. Accessibility Legislation

The cornerstone of U.S. accessibility legislation for websites is the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). The ADA provides a framework that requires that businesses ensure their digital content is accessible to all individuals, including those with disabilities. This legislation not only guides entities in best practices for digital inclusion but also serves as a linchpin for legal accountability.

Throughout 2023, there has been a surge in ADA compliance lawsuits, wherein plaintiffs allege that certain websites are not fully accessible to users with disabilities. According to a summary by UsableNet, 933 businesses using overlays were sued, highlighting a critical compliance risk area. Overlays are often implemented as a quick fix for accessibility barriers but have come under scrutiny for their effectiveness.

The key elements of an ADA checklist for websites typically involve adhering to the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG). These guidelines, while not law, have been widely recognized in legal settings as the standard for measuring a website’s accessibility. WCAG 2.1 has set measurable criteria for accessibility, and entities were also anticipating the release of WCAG 2.2 to further enhance web inclusivity.

It was reported that in 2023, New York and California remained hotspots for website accessibility lawsuits, with New York accounting for nearly 73% of all cases filed nationwide.

While the ADA does not provide explicit instructions for website compliance, court rulings, and settlements have increasingly dictated that websites of public-facing entities should be accessible, potentially influencing the decrease in serial litigation and alterations in the landscape of ADA website compliance.

Enforcement of digital accessibility compliance is primarily carried out through civil lawsuits, where individuals or groups file against companies in federal or state courts. Notably, the legal sector has seen an increase in these types of lawsuits, leading to the inference that businesses should prioritize accessibility to avoid litigation and better serve their users.

Lock On A Keycard

ADA Website Compliance Lawsuits in 2023

The landscape of digital accessibility underwent notable changes in 2023, with a significant impact on website compliance under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). Legal actions related to ADA website compliance have both increased and evolved, shedding light on the increasing importance of digital accessibility.

Recent Trends in ADA Website Lawsuits

Recent data indicate a surge in ADA website compliance lawsuits, with such legal actions escalating in both frequency and scope. Research by UsableNET highlighted that these lawsuits are not confined to large corporations but are increasingly targeting smaller businesses. In particular, companies with annual revenues of less than $25 million are seeing more lawsuits, accounting for 77% of cases. Companies utilizing web overlay widgets, purported to enhance accessibility, have also found themselves embroiled in legal challenges. The importance of genuine and comprehensive accessibility measures has never been more critical.

The Potential Consequences of Non-Compliance

The consequences for businesses failing to adhere to ADA website compliance standards are multifaceted. There are immediate financial implications that arise from legal fees, settlement costs, and the potential for statutory penalties. Beyond the direct financial hit, there’s also the risk of damage to a company’s reputation, customer trust, and overall brand image. As compliance becomes not only a legal requirement but a customer expectation, the impact of non-compliance on consumer sentiment and market position can be substantial and enduring.

Creating an ADA Compliant Online Presence

Businesses and organizations must prioritize creating an ADA-compliant online presence to ensure accessibility for all users. A robust strategy includes both website modification and the potential integration of ADA apps to achieve compliance.

How to Make a Website ADA Compliant

To make a website ADA compliant, it is essential to follow the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG). These guidelines are often considered the standard for web accessibility. Key components include:

  • Text Alternatives: Provide text for non-text content.
  • Time-based Media: Offer alternatives for time-based media like video or audio.
  • Adaptable: Ensure content is presented in different ways, including assistive technologies, without losing meaning.
  • Distinguishable: Make it easier for users to see and hear content.

One reported statistic indicated a significant jump in lawsuits involving “overlays,” which are tools used to enhance, but not replace, fundamental accessibility practices. Website owners must understand that while overlays can aid in compliance, they are not a standalone solution.

Leveraging ADA Apps for Compliance

An ADA app can help businesses become more compliant by identifying and fixing accessibility issues on their websites. These apps work by:

  • Scanning: Regularly scanning websites to detect potential compliance issues.
  • Suggesting Improvements: Providing recommendations for changes that can aid in compliance.
  • Monitoring: Continuously monitoring the website to ensure ongoing compliance as content updates.

An analysis of legal trends shows an increase in digital accessibility claims, with three new plaintiff law firms topping the list for ADA lawsuits in the first half of 2023. Businesses are urged to leverage ADA apps proactively to manage compliance before facing legal challenges.

Digital Icons

Accessibility Features and Best Practices

When addressing ADA compliance for websites, adhering to a set of guidelines ensures that a site is accessible to all users, including those with disabilities. The implementation of specific accessibility features and adherence to best practices are pivotal for compliance.

The ADA Compliance Checklist

The ADA Compliance Checklist serves as a roadmap for website owners to verify that their digital content meets the required accessibility standards. One should not view this checklist as exhaustive, but rather as a starting point for compliance efforts.

  1. Text Alternatives: Provide text alternatives for any non-text content so that it can be changed into other forms people need, such as large print, braille, speech, symbols, or simpler language.
  2. Time-based Media: Offer alternatives for time-based media, including captions and transcripts for audio and video content.
  3. Adaptable Content: Ensure content is presented in different ways without losing information or structure, which is important for assistive technologies.
  4. Distinguishable: Make it easier for users to see and hear content by separating foreground from background.
  5. Keyboard Navigation: All functionality must be accessible via a keyboard to accommodate users who cannot use a mouse.
  6. Sufficient Time: Provide users ample time to read and use content, which is crucial for those who may need more time to understand or interact with the content.
  7. Seizures and Physical Reactions: Design content in a way that it does not cause seizures or physical reactions.
  8. Navigable: Include options to navigate, find content, and determine where one is on the website.
  9. Input Modalities: Make it easier for users to operate functionality through various inputs beyond the keyboard.
  10. Compatibility: Ensure content is compatible with current and future user tools, like assistive technologies.

Tech Solutions for ADA Compliance

As businesses seek to enhance their digital accessibility, technology solutions like Accessibly’s services have become pivotal in navigating the complex landscape of ADA compliance.

How Accessibly’s Services Facilitate Compliance

Accessibly provides a comprehensive suite of tools that can significantly ease the burden of adapting websites to meet ADA compliance standards. Their services include automated scans and reports that identify the specific sections of a website that may not comply with the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG). These are the guidelines typically referenced in ADA-related lawsuits, as evident from the rise in such legal actions in recent years.

Once areas for improvement are identified, Accessibly aids in remediation by providing detailed instructions on how to resolve each issue. Their solutions are not one-size-fits-all; instead, they tailor their advice to the unique elements of each client’s website. They focus on key accessibility features such as:

  • Screen reader compatibility: Ensuring that website content is fully accessible to visually impaired users.
  • Keyboard navigation optimization: Making sure that all functionalities can be operated through the keyboard interface.
  • Contrast ratio adjustments: Addressing visual accessibility challenges through proper color contrast that meets WCAG standards.

Furthermore, Accessibly remains up-to-date with the ongoing changes to accessibility guidelines. This proficiency ensures that clients can maintain compliance even as standards evolve. The service emphasizes building a web environment that is inclusive and user-friendly for people with disabilities, a factor that has become increasingly important as reflected in the growing number of accessibility lawsuits.

In an era where digital presence is crucial, Accessibly’s blend of thorough evaluation, actionable insights, and ongoing support positions them as a key ally for businesses in their pursuit of ADA compliance.

Tablet Support Screen

Evaluating Accessibility on Current Websites

When assessing the accessibility of current websites, compliance professionals perform a multi-faceted evaluation. Key components include the following:

  • Automated Testing Tools: These are used to quickly identify code-based issues against established standards, such as the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG).
  • Manual Audits: Skilled experts review the website to catch nuances that automated tools might miss.

The evaluation process encompasses various elements:

  • Contrast Ratios: Checks to ensure text stands out against background colors to accommodate users with low vision.
  • Keyboard Navigation: Ensures all interactive elements are fully operable through keyboard-only interaction.
  • Screen Reader Compatibility: Confirms that content is structured in a way that is comprehensible to screen readers used by individuals who are blind or have low vision.

A common standard websites aim to meet is WCAG 2.1 AA. This includes:

  • Alt Text for Images: Providing descriptions for non-text content.
  • Video Captions: Adding captions to multimedia for users with hearing disabilities.

Defending Against ADA Compliance Lawsuits

When an organization faces an ADA compliance lawsuit related to its website, there are several steps they can take to mount a robust defense:

  1. Audit the Website: They should immediately conduct a thorough audit of their website to assess its accessibility. Using tools and guidelines like the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) can help identify areas that require improvement.
  2. Consult Legal Experts: Retaining an attorney who specializes in digital accessibility litigation can provide guidance tailored to the specific claims made in the lawsuit.
  3. Document Compliance Efforts: Documentation of any ongoing or previous efforts to comply with ADA guidelines can demonstrate a proactive approach to accessibility, potentially mitigating legal repercussions.
  4. Engage with Plaintiffs: Responding promptly and openly to plaintiff communication may lead to a resolution without lengthy court proceedings.
  5. Remediate Quickly: Once accessibility issues are identified, prioritize their resolution. Quick action can show commitment to accessibility and possibly influence legal outcomes.
  6. Preventive Measures:
    • Continuous Monitoring: Regularly reviewing and updating the website ensures sustained compliance.
    • Training: Providing staff with accessibility training can prevent future compliance issues.

By rigorously assessing their websites and proactively addressing accessibility concerns, organizations can defend against ADA compliance lawsuits more effectively and reinforce their commitment to ensuring access for all users.

The Role of Web Developers in ADA Compliance

Web developers play a critical role in ensuring websites meet ADA compliance standards. Their responsibilities include:

  • Implementing Accessible Design: They must integrate accessibility principles into the website’s design phase, focusing on creating interfaces that can be used by everyone, including individuals with disabilities.
  • Coding for Accessibility: Semantic HTML, proper use of ARIA roles, and ensuring keyboard navigability are among the coding best practices that developers must adhere to for compliance.

Key Areas of Focus for Web Developers:

  1. Text Alternatives: Provide text for non-text content.
  2. Media Alternatives: Offer captions and other alternatives for multimedia.
  3. Adaptable: Create content that can be presented in different ways.
  4. Distinguishable: Make it easier for users to see and hear content.

Testing for Compliance:

  • Automated Testing: Utilize tools to identify potential compliance issues.
  • Manual Testing: Conduct thorough manual tests, often involving community members with disabilities.
  • Continuous Evaluation: Regularly review the site to maintain compliance as standards and content evolve.

As 2023 saw an increase in lawsuits related to the use of inaccessible overlays, the importance of developers’ understanding of compliance has become more critical. They must not only use compliant frameworks but also recognize the potential for certain widgets to become accessibility barriers. Web developers should thus approach ADA compliance as an ongoing commitment, ensuring their websites are inclusive and legally compliant.

Future Projections: ADA Compliance and Digital Spaces

As digital technology evolves, businesses are increasingly mindful of the importance of ADA compliance in their online environments. Trends indicate a continual rise in the number of website accessibility lawsuits, with particular scrutiny on small companies with less than $25 million in annual revenue.

Key Projections:

  • Growing Litigation: With the number of web accessibility lawsuits having already set a record in 2022, the trajectory suggests a sustained increase as more plaintiffs advocate for equal access in digital spaces.
  • Small Business Impact: Smaller enterprises will likely face heightened legal risk due to a significant percentage of such lawsuits targeting them, as seen in the first half of 2023.
  • Compliance Efforts: A large majority of websites still fail to meet accessibility standards. Much-needed compliance efforts may see an upswing due to this litigation trend.

Data Snapshot:

  • Websites Compliant: A meager 3.7%
  • Potential Increase in Lawsuits: Up to 4x since 2018

ADA compliance will likely become integral to digital strategy moving forward. Proactive adjustments and investments in accessibility, like the Accessibly widget, is key in minimizing your legal exposure and embodying digital inclusivity.

Thumbnail Of Kaspars Milbergs

Article by Kaspars Milbergs

Last updated


Get The #1 Accessibility Widget Now

Install Accessibly and make your website ADA & WCAG compliant at a moment’s notice.

Get Accessibly App
Photo with animation